Our System for Rating Wine
Wine ratings can be helpful, but they should never be the only reason you buy a bottle. At Vino Critic, we use both a 100-point score and a 5-star rating because each one serves a different purpose. The 100-point scale gives us more room to be specific. The 5-star scale gives readers a quick, easy way to understand whether we would actually recommend the wine in real life.
How We Rate Wine
We use the 100-point scale to give each wine a more precise score, and we use the 5-star scale to explain how we feel about the wine in plain English. A 100-point score helps compare wines more directly, while the star rating helps answer the more practical question: would we buy this wine again, recommend it to friends, or save it for a special occasion?
Ratings Matter, But They Do Not Tell the Whole Story
Wine scores are useful, but they can also be misleading if you treat them like absolute truth. A 92-point wine is not automatically the best wine for every person, every meal, or every budget. A lower-rated wine may be exactly what you want if it fits your taste, your food, or the occasion better.
The difference between an 89-point wine and a 90-point wine can seem huge in retail, but for most actual wine drinkers, that one-point difference may not be noticeable. A 90-point wine often gets more attention simply because it crosses a marketing threshold. That does not always mean it is meaningfully better than an 88 or 89.
That is why we try to explain the wine beyond the number. We want readers to understand what the wine tastes like, what kind of drinker may enjoy it, what foods it works with, whether it is a good value, and whether we would actually buy it again.
Why We Use the 100-Point Wine Rating Scale
The 100-point scale is the most common way wine is scored by major publications, critics, and wine reviewers. We use it because it gives us more flexibility than a simple 5-star rating. It allows us to separate wines that may both be “good,” but not equally strong.
For example, two wines may both deserve 4 stars, but one might be a solid 88-point bottle and the other might be a memorable 93-point bottle. The 100-point score gives us more room to show that difference.
100-Point Wine Rating Chart
| Score | What It Means | How We Think About It |
|---|---|---|
| 95–100 | Classic / exceptional wine | A standout bottle that delivers a special experience and would be memorable long after drinking it. |
| 90–94 | Outstanding wine | A wine with superior character, balance, quality, and personality. One we would confidently recommend. |
| 85–89 | Very good wine | A well-made wine with special qualities. Often a very smart buy if the price is right. |
| 80–84 | Good wine | A solid, drinkable, well-made wine that may be enjoyable but does not stand out. |
| 75–79 | Mediocre wine | Drinkable, but not something we would usually seek out or recommend unless there is a very specific reason. |
| 50–74 | Not recommended | A wine with enough issues that we would not recommend buying it. |
What Goes Into a Wine Score?
When we rate a wine, we are not just asking whether we personally liked it. We are also looking at how well it performs for its style, grape, region, price, and intended audience. A simple weeknight wine and a special-occasion bottle should not be judged in exactly the same way.
Appearance
Color, clarity, depth, age clues, and whether the wine looks healthy in the glass.
Aroma
Fruit, floral, spice, oak, earth, minerality, freshness, complexity, and any flaws.
Flavor
The actual taste of the wine, including fruit character, oak, sweetness, spice, earth, and finish.
Body & Texture
Whether the wine feels light, medium, full, creamy, silky, plush, thin, heavy, smooth, or grippy.
Acidity & Tannins
Freshness, balance, structure, astringency, grip, and whether the wine feels harsh or well-integrated.
Overall Quality
Balance, complexity, finish, value, drinkability, style accuracy, and whether we would recommend it.
Why We Also Use a 5-Star Rating
The 5-star scale is less precise than the 100-point scale, but it is easier to understand at a glance. It is also more natural for online reviews because most readers already understand what 1 star, 3 stars, or 5 stars means.
We use stars to communicate our practical opinion: would we avoid this wine, tolerate it, buy it again, recommend it, or remember it as something special?
5-Star Wine Rating Chart
| Rating | Quick Meaning | How We Feel About It |
|---|---|---|
| 0 Stars | Undrinkable | We would not drink this wine again, even if it were the only option. |
| 1 Star | Only if we have no choice | A last-resort wine. Maybe at a stadium, company picnic, or event with no better option. |
| 2 Stars | Acceptable, but not preferred | It does the job, but we would not usually buy it unless it were deeply discounted or one of the only options available. |
| 3 Stars | Good wine | A pleasant wine we would buy again. It may not be unforgettable, but it is enjoyable and worth drinking. |
| 4 Stars | Memorable wine | A wine we would recommend, remember, and be excited to share with other wine lovers. |
| 5 Stars | Exceptional / perfect experience | A wine that feels like an experience, not just a drink. The kind of bottle you remember long after it is gone. |
What Each Star Rating Really Means
0 Stars: Undrinkable
We would not drink this wine again, even if it were our only option. In school terms, this is an F.
1 Star: Only If We Have No Choice
We would drink this only if there were no better options available. Think stadium wine, company picnic wine, or a bottle where we would not feel bad if some of it went unfinished.
2 Stars: It Will Do the Job
This wine is drinkable, but it would not be our first choice. It might be fine as a basic house wine, wedding wine, or a bottle we would consider only if the price were very low.
3 Stars: Good Wine
This is good wine. We would spend our own money on it and consider buying it again. It may not be something we rave about the next day, but it is pleasant and can complement a simple meal.
4 Stars: Memorable Wine
This wine is not only good, it is memorable. We would recommend it to friends, share it with fellow wine lovers, and consider saving it for a special occasion. If we found it at a great price, we would be tempted to buy more than one bottle.
5 Stars: A Special Wine Experience
This is the kind of wine that feels like an experience, not just a drink. It is the bottle that makes you want to save the cork or label, even if your spouse or friends look at you like you are crazy. They just do not understand.
How You Should Use Our Wine Ratings
The best way to use our ratings is to treat them as guidance, not rules. A high score tells you that we believe the wine is well-made and worth considering. But the tasting notes, food pairings, style description, price, and your own preferences matter just as much.
For example, if you dislike oaky Chardonnay, a highly rated buttery Chardonnay still may not be the right bottle for you. If you love sweet Riesling, a lower-rated bottle that matches your taste might bring you more enjoyment than a technically better dry wine.
The point of our ratings is not to tell you what you are supposed to like. The point is to help you make a better decision before you spend your money.
Why the Same Wine Can Score Differently Year to Year
A wine’s rating can change from vintage to vintage. A 2016 bottle may not taste exactly like the 2017 version of the same wine. Weather, growing conditions, harvesting decisions, winemaking choices, oak aging, bottle age, and storage can all affect the final result.
That is why we encourage readers to pay attention to the vintage, not just the producer or wine name. A winery may have a great track record, but each vintage still deserves to be judged on its own.
Your Taste Matters More Than Any Score
The most important thing to remember is that you are your own judge. Some people love sweet wines. Some people avoid them. Some people want big tannic reds. Others prefer lighter, softer, fruitier wines. Some people love oak. Others find it overwhelming.
Your palate will also change over time. The more wine you taste, the more your preferences will sharpen. You may start noticing acidity, tannins, body, oak, sweetness, minerality, and finish in ways you did not before.
That is part of what makes wine fun. A review can point you in the right direction, but your own taste should always have the final say.
Wine Rating Questions
Is a 90-point wine always better than an 89-point wine?
Not necessarily. A 90-point score can matter a lot in marketing, but most wine drinkers may not notice a meaningful difference between an 89 and a 90. The style, price, food pairing, and your own taste matter too.
Why use both a 100-point score and a 5-star rating?
The 100-point score gives us more precision, while the 5-star rating is easier to understand quickly. Together, they give readers both detail and a simple recommendation.
Can a lower-rated wine still be a good buy?
Yes. A lower-rated wine can still be a good buy if it is affordable, fits your taste, works well with your food, or serves the occasion. Value matters.
Do wine ratings change by vintage?
Yes. The same wine can taste different from year to year because growing conditions, winemaking choices, bottle age, and storage can all affect the final result.
Should I trust my own taste over a wine score?
Yes. A wine score can help guide you, but your own taste matters most. The best wine for you is the one you enjoy drinking.
Our Ratings Are a Guide, Not a Rulebook
We rate wines to help readers make better buying decisions, not to tell anyone what they are required to like. The 100-point scale gives us precision, while the 5-star scale gives a quick real-world recommendation. But the best way to use any wine review is to read the score, tasting notes, style description, food pairing advice, and price together. A great wine score is helpful, but your own taste always matters most.
Practical Wine Reviews for Real Wine Drinkers
Vino Critic is written for people who want wine to feel understandable, useful, and enjoyable. Our rating system is designed to combine practical buying advice with honest tasting impressions, so readers can choose wines that fit their taste, meal, budget, and occasion.
One Response
🔏 Transfer to you. SIGN IN >>> graph.org/BALANCE-36824-US-DOLLARS-04-24?hs=a60eb9eebee50bab6ceeba34bc60346d&
x4uqbx